Assert That VS Xray: Best BDD App Integrated Into Jira

When it comes to the integration of Behavior-Driven Development (BDD) into Jira, two tools such as AssertThat and Xray come into play. Both are designed for teams who wish to improve interaction and reduce the efforts of testing processes. However, their features and how they are put into use are quite different. So, in this article, we are going to provide a detailed comparison of AssertThat and Xray so that you can choose the best BDD app that best matches the requirements of your project.

AssertThat Overview

AssertThat is a powerful BDD app for Jira. BDD can be defined as the process of writing and managing, and running scenarios in Jira. Due to its ease of use and integration with Jira, teams that apply and ensure BDD methodologies find AssertThat to be one of the tools worth using. AssertThat is focused on the BDD development practices. Thus it is ideal for teams who want to ensure smooth collaboration between development and business teams.

Key Features

Native Jira Integration

With AssertThat, teams are able to handle the BDD scenarios directly in the context of Jira issues. This ensures that all the processes are properly organized in a single place. This integration guarantees that all the phases of testing will correspond to everything else in the development cycle without the need for external resources.

Step Autocomplete and Scenario Management

With this feature, you will get a lot of steps to easily autocomplete while writing scenarios. This makes the writing process quite easy preventing you from writing errors and eliminating the writing time as well. Moreover, teams are able to handle more than one scenario at a time due to the app’s bulk update option.

Linking Scenarios to User Stories

AssertThat enables you to link BDD scenarios to Jira user stories. This makes the whole information accessible to all the team members.

Test Automation

With AssertThat you can automate test results and import them into Jira. With this option, you can view the manual and automated statuses in one place.

Reporting

Another great feature of AssertThat is its interactive and traceable reporting system. The system enables users to view both user stories and BDD scenarios through advanced reports and charts. This enhances the team’s analytical processes related to the test plan statuses and automation performance.

Other Features

Gherkin editor

AssertThat has a built-inGherkin editor. It stands out with auto-formatting, auto-completion, and syntax validation options.

Customizable Dashboards

AssertThat’s customizable dashboards aim at cross-project reporting. Teams can track the project status, performance, and other crucial metric that will help them improve the workflow.

Advanced Filtering and Bulk Operations

The app enables a smart filtering process to find the scenarios by feature or scenario name, tag, mode, or related issue. With this, AssertThat makes scenario management even easier than you might think.

Customer Support

AssertThat stands out with its fast-responding 24/7 support service in case of any issues o inquiries.

APIs and Integrations

The app easily integrates with such CI/CD pipelines as Gradle, Maven, Ruby, Node.js, and Jenkins. So, users can smoothly implement the BDD system into their already existing workflows.

Safety and Security

AssertThat is highly reliable and performance-oriented due to its cloud-fortified nature. Moreover, the app participates in the Bug Bounty program across all platforms. So, users can make sure of the tool’s secure and safe usage.

Xray Overview

Xray is also a great test management solution for Jira. It offers both manual and automated testing processes for the team. Even though it is not exclusively a Behaviour-Driven Development app, its advanced BDD features make it suitable for teams with various testing needs.

Key Features of Xray

Test Management Features

With Xray, teams can cover the whole testing flow. The app offers a great solution starting from test planning to thorough reporting. The supported testing methods of Xray are as follows:

Exploratory testing
Manual testing
Automated testing

BDD Integration

The app supports Gherkin syntax. With this, Xray assists teams in creating and managing BDD scenarios while integrating them into their development pipelines. Even though Xray isn’t exclusively a BDD tool, its BDD features are quite enough to handle difficult scenarios, especially when multiple testing types are needed.

Automated Testing

Integrating with CI/CD pipelines and major testing frameworks, Xray ensures a smooth automation process. This is especially important for teams that have automation as a priority while also managing manual tests in the working process.

Detailed Reporting and Metrics

Xray gives the teams an opportunity to maintain the highest quality of standards delivering comprehensive analytics and metrics. With its customizable reports, Xray is suitable for different teams’ needs such as high-level overviews or detailed execution logs.

Customizable Workflows

Xray adapts to Agile and DevOps, which enables to offer flexibility for various types of projects. With this, teams can customize the app to meet their specific workflow. This is crucial, especially for larger teams.

AssertThat VS Xray: Detailed Comparison

When choosing an app to implement Behavior-Driven Development (BDD) into Jira, AssertThat outshines as a great solution tailored specifically for teams practicing the BDD system. Both AssertThat and Xray offer great features to implement BDD in Jira and enhance the team’s functionality and overall workflow. At this point, we are going to compare both tools to understand what team needs they serve best.

Native Jira Integration

In the aspect of native Jira integration, AssertThat allows teams to manage BDD scenarios directly within Jira issues. So, with this integration, all the processes starting from scenario creation to the final execution remain in one centralized place. This eliminates the need to use more external tools. Furthermore, linking the scenarios to user stories on Jira enables all the team members to always have access to the comprehensive information which, in turn,

Even though Xray also integrates with Jira, it is tailored to broader test management workflows. Its BDD features are a part of a feature set, that makes it less focused on teams that want to exclusively implement BDD.

Scenario Management and Automation

AssertThat offers step autocomplete, bulk updates, and other features to quickly write scenarios with Gherkin syntax using autocomplete functionality to reduce errors and save time. AssertThat’s ability to manage multiple scenarios at a time makes it a great feature for complex projects. AssertThat makes the overall working process smoother by providing a unified system of manual and automated test statuses.

While offering strong automation and integration with CI/CD pipelines, Xray doesn’t offer strong BDD scenario management. Even though it supports BDD the app lacks AssertThat’s advanced tools like step autocomplete or bulk operations.

Reporting and Metrics

AssertThat offers an interactive traceability report for BDD. This enables the teams to view user stories and scenarios in real-time with advanced charts and reports. So, the team has a great analytical toolkit which, in turn, will make the workflow smoother and more effective.

Xray also offers detailed reporting and customizable analytical metrics. However, these features are spread across various testing methodologies. So, this may make it less clear for those teams that practice BDD compared to AssertThat.

Pricing

AssertThat offers a free version for teams having up to 10 members. For teams with more members and project participants, there is a customizable pricing system. For instance, businesses should pay $275 for 100 users per month.

While Xray does not offer a free version, it gives a free trial opportunity. However, its pricing is much more expensive, charging $550 for teams with 100 members on a monthly basis.

In this case, AssertThat is an affordable advanced app for those who want to implement BDD in Jira.

To Wrap Things Up…

Both AssertThat and Xray offer advanced features to integrate BDD into Jira. However, AssertThat outshines as an ideal choice for teams that are fully focused on BDD practices due to its advanced features and user-friendly design.

Being specifically designed for BDD, AssertThat provides a strong toolkit for teams that prioritize BDD workflows. It makes the scenario execution, management, and reporting smoother and precise In contrast to Xray, AssertThat focuses mainly on BDD integration, which helps to reduce the unnecessary complexity, making it quite simple to use. Besides, in comparison to Xray, it is more affordable offering a free version for startups and small teams.

In conclusion, both tools offer robust features for various purposes for teams. For those who want to focus mainly on BDD solutions, AssertThat is a great choice. At the same time, Xray focuses on broader test management workflows. AssertThat’s BDD-specialized features, easy usage, and advanced integrations make it super efficient to manage workflows in Jira.

Author
Recent Posts

Anahit V.

Anahit is creating engaging and informative content for various industries. With a strong passion for writing, and a talent for crafting content that connects with readers, delivers value, and meets the objectives of clients. She has a proven track record of producing high-quality content for websites, blogs, social media, and other digital platforms.